Steel or Graphite Shafts For High Handicappers

Last update:
steel or graphite shaft for high handicapper

Higher handicaps can select between steel and graphite shafts based on their swing style, budget, and physical condition.

Steel shafts are sturdy and long-lasting, while graphite shafts offer forgiveness and are lighter. Graphite is better suited for those with slower swings or physical limitations, whereas steel could offer more immediate feedback.

Custom testing and fitting sessions can assist in identifying the most suitable shaft type to enhance performance on the course.

Steel or Graphite Shafts

Well, there is a lot of confusion when choosing between steel and graphite shafts, or any other golf shafts, especially for high handicappers.

While both shafts have pros and cons, understanding their key differences can help you make the right choice.

Pros and Cons of Graphite Shafts

Helps generate clubhead speedHigher cost compared to steel shafts
Lightweight for easier swingDurability concerns as technique improves
Absorbs shock for mishitsLimited options for customization in some cases
Ideal for players with slower swingsCan feel too light for some players
Less strain on joints and muscles
Provides consistency in flex

Pros and Cons of Steel Shafts

Durability for long-term useCan be harder to launch the ball for players with slow swings
Better control over shot shapeLess forgiving on mishits
Helps in developing muscle strengthMay cause more strain on joints and muscles over time
Generally less expensive than graphite
Offers a traditional look and feel
Provides consistent performance

So, Which One Is Right For You?

Graphite shafts are often preferred due to their forgiving nature, which minimizes distance loss and promotes straighter shots.

With graphite shafts, you can swing more efficiently and improve your performance with irons.

If the swing speed of a high handicapper is already fast, steel shafts might offer better control and stability. As a result of their direct feedback, steel shafts are more responsive and comfortable for some players.

However, a budget consideration is also relevant since steel shafts are generally cheaper than graphite.

In the end, hands-on testing and experimentation are the best ways to determine the correct shaft.

Who Should Use Graphite Shaft?

A graphite shaft is the best choice for high handicappers who struggle with swing speed, consistency, or fatigue. Specifically:

  • Graphite shafts are lighter and help generate clubhead speed, making them ideal for players with slower swings.
  • Graphite’s forgiveness minimizes distance loss and promotes straight shots. It improves overall scoring for inconsistency-prone people.
  • Players with physical limitations or injuries may find graphite shafts easier to handle and less taxing on the body.
  • Older players with a decline in swing speed benefit from graphite’s ability to minimize strain and maintain distance.
  • Many prefer graphite shafts for their vibration-dampening properties and comfort.

Steel or Graphite Shaft: Considering Factors

High handicappers should consider several key factors when choosing between steel or graphite shafts:

animated golfer
  • Flexibility:

Graphite shafts tend to be more flexible than steel. It enables high handicappers to make solid contact and maintain consistency.

  • Weight and Balance:

As steel shafts are heavier than graphite, they provide stability and consistency. Faster acceleration and lower resistance are possible.

  • Consistency and Feedback:

Steel shafts provide immediate feedback and consistency, improving technique. Graphite shafts offer a more forgiving, neutral feel that may mask mishits.

  • Swing Speed and Tempo:

 High handicappers with slower swing speeds may benefit from the lighter weight of graphite shafts. As a result, they can generate a faster clubhead.

  • Launch Angle and Spin Rate:

A graphite shaft has a higher launch angle and spin rate than a steel shaft. It can be helpful in high handicappers looking to maximize carry distance and control.

  • Cost and Durability:

The cost and durability of graphite shafts are higher. They are more affordable and maintain playability over multiple seasons.

  • Club Head Performance:

 Graphite allows for higher launches and spin rates for softer landings, while steel reduces ball flights.

  • Custom Fitting:

A custom fitting considers swing speed, launch angle, and feel preferences. This process often results in a split-set approach for improved playability.

Is Graphite Shafts Useful For High Handicappers?

Yes, graphite shafts are lighter, aiding slower swings and minimizing strain. Thus improving overall performance.

Also, Graphite shafts can reduce the overall weight of the golf club, making it easier to swing.

They dampen vibrations, which can help golfers with slower swing speeds hit the ball straighter. Finally, graphite shafts can help you to gain more distance with their shots.

Are Steel Shafts More Durable Than Graphite Shafts?

Yes, steel shafts generally offer superior durability and longevity than graphite shafts.

Steel shafts are generally more durable than graphite shafts but are also heavier and stiffer.

Slower swing speed golfers may be unable to hit the ball straighter with steel shafts. They are also cheaper, making them an attractive option for high handicappers.

Importance Of Custom Fitting

Custom fitting can help high handicappers find the best shaft for their game. Improving clubhead speed and hitting the ball straighter with a custom shaft is possible.

Furthermore, custom fitting can help golfers find the right shaft for their height, weight, and strength. It can also help to reduce their score, as clubs can be fitted to optimize the ball flight.

You can also choose the suitable shaft material based on their swing speed and strength with custom fitting. 


Should high handicappers use steel or graphite shafts?

The choice between steel and graphite shafts for irons and wedges depends on swing speed and preference, offering flexibility to tailor equipment to individual playing styles.

What is the best type of shaft for a high handicapper?

The best type of shaft for a high handicapper is the graphite shaft because it provides greater distance. Those who can’t determine their shot length can benefit from it.

Photo of author


Hey, I am Allen Jackson a golf expert with over 30 years of experience. From my childhood, I have found my passion. I played on high school and college teams and went on to become a professional golfer. Now, I am a full-time trainer.